Silence?
Silence is brass, speech is gold.
- We are biased. As a humanistically oriented cultural consultancy, we are guided by the values of respect, science orientation, love for humanity, and self-reflection. We are aware of our fallibility and therefore look to Pico della Mirandola's work: On the Dignity of Man, a foundational text of humanism. We are biased and put our bias up for discussion. We don’t want to simply leave the space of narratives to other voices; we want to emphasize that our story - the story of modernity, the Enlightenment, humanism - has a place in the emotionally charged debate with other narratives. We claim the right to tell, to speak, and in doing so explore how we can share knowledge without overriding others.
- We have a basic thesis and we are referring to companies. To ensure a peaceful working atmosphere, companies follow an unspoken rule: avoid controversial topics, especially sexuality, religion, and politics. A way to avoid conflicts that are seen as unproductive and harmful. In an overall homogeneous value world, this is socially smart. But nowadays, we no longer live in a homogeneous value world even within companies – what is seen as a societal split is a fundamental disagreement in value-oriented attitudes, with a significant impact on the possibilities for respectful and solution-oriented communication.
Something has fundamentally changed and it is gaining momentum. And here we notice that staying silent or withdrawing actively supports another aggressive and self-interest-oriented attitude. So our basic thesis is, anyone who stays silent supports what they reject in their inner dialogue.
The damage is significant, and it has two perspectives:
1. A societal perspective. A company is an essential part of our society, where reality is shaped by its values. So our communication behavior, and silence or withdrawal being forms of communication, influence which narrative gains traction in society. We have a responsibility in the spaces where narratives take hold.
2. From the company's point of view, our withdrawal, our doubts, our perfectly legitimate silence, affects motivation and engagement. The attitude shown by the CEO of the VW subsidiary AUDI has an impact – the sense of connection and belonging, which are key factors for engagement and motivation, become weaker.
BMW has positioned itself differently (though they already have their largest factory in the USA), they took away the BMW company car from the President of the State Parliament of Saxony-Anhalt. A very different gesture. - What has changed? Let's start with an example: Elon Musk said, "The fundamental weakness of Western civilization is empathy." Now, empathy is one of the cornerstones of modern leadership teachings and is often accompanied by the value: compassion. In German, this is most closely translated as Barmherzigkeit (mercy). Who says this? Someone who comes from a South African family deeply involved in apartheid and, if translated into a German linguistic framework, assumes a superior group of people who have more rights than other groups in society – in short, a white master race. To keep the other, inferior groups down, empathy is a disturbing concept – coldness and mercilessness is an attitude that helps within this concept. The idea of universal human rights is obsolete in this attitude. And in the background is the idea of limited resources, which the group that feels superior claims as their possession.
Do you know which group they belong to? For us, these attitudes mean a fundamental change in the prerequisites for successful communication. All recommendations and tips for good communication become obsolete. We had a consensus that we aim for a win-win situation, that we treat the other with respect and appreciation, that we speak on equal footing, and that we base ourselves on a scientifically oriented perspective on facts. We tried to eliminate the power aspect from communication. We are often somewhat surprised by the changing attitude: no win-win, but only one can win: win-lose is the orientation, and to win, any means are justified. The deeper prerequisite: There is a group that has the right to dominate, to take, to claim, and to exclude. Communication is the exercise of power.
And the new leadership model? Fear, arbitrariness, and nepotism as the new art of leadership. Instead of reading Erich Fromm, read Machiavelli. And here all our communication recommendations fail: thinking systemically? Asking circular questions? Responding to the needs of the other person, establishing a yes set? What to do when arguments always go ad hominem, always at the person, always demeaning? It seems as if our communicative attitude plays into the hands of those who see communication as a tool of power. It seems as if we are signaling helplessness. How can we communicate when we no longer have a common ground? Do we get angry? Do we withdraw and, falling into the impossibility of conversation, remain silent? - We continue to try to understand and look for ways to engage in a transformative conversation. Nietzsche, and following him Max Scheler, provide a model for understanding with their thoughts on ressentiment. What is ressentiment, ultimately, as a morally creating force? Someone or a group experiences a sense of injury, inferiority, or injustice in their inner experience. They don’t see their own ability to act or change. The anger and hostility rooted in that anger persist and solidify. The coping strategy to escape one’s own powerlessness is a fundamental reinterpretation: the Other is turned into morally bad, despicable, while one sees oneself as good and just. In ressentiment, one’s own powerlessness becomes moral strength and creates an evil opponent. In this movement, one becomes good oneself – one takes over morality and reinterprets it. This creates a morally charged hostility that is vented on others: the evil, the stupid, etc
Nietzsche sees this movement not only in those he associates with a slave morality, but also in those who distance themselves from the hostile, self-exalting ressentiment. Here he calls for self-reflection and, indeed, modesty.
So, what does this model tell us? First, it lets us understand helplessness behind the facade of strength and moral superiority. Just look at how relentlessly Trump targets Obama. Through an empathetic understanding, we can grasp the injuries, the feeling of being shortchanged. We might even understand how a desire to be noticed, to be acknowledged in one’s own needs, becomes so palpable. However, our empathetic understanding doesn’t change how we can successfully engage in conversation with each other. It should, however, help us follow Nietzsche’s call for self-reflection, because we ourselves may also be trapped in the snare of ressentiment, that is, our own moral self-boosting and slipping into the communication pattern of ‘ad hominem,’ demeaning the other person. - Ways out of silence? Silence and withdrawal are a form of coping in situations where understanding seems impossible. It leaves room for other voices. Flood the zone with shit. You can also flood it with other content.
The current Prime Minister of the United Kingdom is Andy Burnham. He formulated an important approach to change with his statement that we need to invest in the communities, because that’s where the reality of life is created. Invest in the communities, in the societal foundation. What does that mean for companies? Right now, we’re mostly seeing top-down change projects. A fairly distant elite of leadership tells people through their consultants what needs to be changed. Quite often with a slap at the people – you’re not performing enough, you’re not working enough, you still haven’t understood the signs of the times, etc. It’s an implicitly derogatory form of communication, a potential hurt that can lead to coping through resentment. In the few bottom-up, middle-up approaches we’re currently supporting, we see how hungry people are for real involvement. That was the success factor of Kaizen/CIP – people could feel, I shape my company together with others, we are needed, our ideas are being noticed.
It wasn’t just the methods that brought measurable success, but this bottom-up movement where people could experience themselves as co-creators. Burnham picks this up when he understands that a change in attitude can’t happen from the top, it has to come from the bottom up. But when it becomes noticeable in a company that hierarchical, top-down, patriarchal behavior is tolerated because the numbers are right, people turn away and start to doubt whether the company is still the right place for them. Those who stay out of insecurity and fear end up staying with reduced engagement. Raising your voice is always associated with the risk of being rejected, and the newly forming communication culture is threatening in its aggressiveness. There's a saying: 'We are more.' The 'more' is true, but not the 'we.' It's necessary to find friends, to form a 'we.' This also happens on different levels, and if we want to influence the contents of our reality, it can only happen bottom-up, both in companies and in society.
Lula's unlikely re-election in Brazil is based on the power of groups that got involved in a 'we' without worrying about the risks. The success of the student party in Serbia is due to consistently building a 'we' in society. Raising your voice and finding others who raise theirs. One of the most dangerous weapons in communication as a tool of power is creating fear. Serbia, Brazil, and others give good reason to hope that humanistically oriented attitudes can prevail. The CEO of AUDI didn't understand this – he made it clear that he supports the attitude: Those who have power are right. A surefire way to demotivate.
Top leadership should understand: Our company is not just the top management with advisors, but the diverse sum of all employees, that’s where your energy lies.

